I have been working in this company [for three years]. (2025)

S

stephenlearner

Senior Member

Chinese

  • Mar 20, 2020
  • #1

Hi,

In the following sentences, does the sentence without "for three years" work? In other words, can I omit the time reference?
I have been working in this company for three years. It's a very difficult work experience. I decide to quit it and change a company.
I have been working in this company. It's a very difficult work experience. I decide to quit it and change a company.

Thank you very much.

Last edited:

  • lingobingo

    Senior Member

    London

    English - England

    • Mar 20, 2020
    • #2

    No, it doesn’t work. And to change a company is not what you mean either. I have been working in this company [for three years]. (2)

    Myridon

    Senior Member

    Texas

    English - US

    • Mar 20, 2020
    • #3

    No.
    I work at X. I don't like it there. I'm going to quit.

    S

    stephenlearner

    Senior Member

    Chinese

    • Mar 20, 2020
    • #4

    I have seen sentences like "I have been working/sleeping" without a time reference. What does it mean?

    Florentia52

    Modwoman in the attic

    Wisconsin

    English - United States

    • Mar 20, 2020
    • #5

    stephenlearner said:

    I have seen sentences like "I have been working/sleeping" without a time reference. What does it mean?

    Please give us the context in which the sentence was used.

    S

    stephenlearner

    Senior Member

    Chinese

    • Mar 20, 2020
    • #6

    I saw it in a grammar book. It did not provide contexts. It just said it you omitted the time reference, it did not matter. It meant the same.

    I have found these examples in the American English corpus:

    1. According to Esposito, the team has been working hard at this and is hoping it will lead to better results this weekend.
    2.The new drill's been working fine. Its not the greatest drill ever and I plan to buy a nice...
    3. making of them gets a tad tricky at times... # So I've been working on a Project. Not for a client per se, more the personal interest
    4. So, what are you going to DO about it? # God has been working me over with some simple, yet powerful, reminders from His Word. Not

    I can't quote more contexts beyond these, because the system just shows these incomplete sentences.

    lingobingo

    Senior Member

    London

    English - England

    • Mar 20, 2020
    • #7

    All those examples are fine because the construction makes sense within the given context. But in your example, by removing the information about having worked there for three years, you’ve taken away the relevant context.

    S

    stephenlearner

    Senior Member

    Chinese

    • Mar 20, 2020
    • #8

    If I add some more information, does it work?
    I worked in another company a while ago. Later I came to this company. I have been working in this company. It's a very difficult work experience. I decide to quit it and change a company.

    lingobingo

    Senior Member

    London

    English - England

    • Mar 20, 2020
    • #9

    No. What else would you do in a company but work there? The context of having been there long enough for the following statement to apply has been removed.

    heypresto

    Senior Member

    South East England

    English - England

    • Mar 20, 2020
    • #10

    I have been working in this company [for three years]. (8)

    I have been working here for 2/3/4 years. I have been working in this company [for three years]. (9)
    I have been working here far too long. I have been working in this company [for three years]. (10)
    I have been working here ever since. I have been working in this company [for three years]. (11)

    I have been working here. I have been working in this company [for three years]. (12)

    S

    stephenlearner

    Senior Member

    Chinese

    • Mar 20, 2020
    • #11

    Cannot "I have been working in this company" mean "I have been working in this company since I came to this company" in that context ?

    Florentia52

    Modwoman in the attic

    Wisconsin

    English - United States

    • Mar 20, 2020
    • #12

    I can't think of a context in which saying "I have been working in this company" (by itself, without additional words) would be meaningful.

    What would you mean by saying "I have been working in this company since I came to this company?" Unless most people come to the company and don't work, it's simply redundant.

    V

    Vronsky

    Senior Member

    Russian - Russia

    • Mar 20, 2020
    • #13

    heypresto said:

    I have been working here. I have been working in this company [for three years]. (14)

    “Why is everything in a mess?”
    “I've been working here.”

    Doesn't this work?

    lingobingo

    Senior Member

    London

    English - England

    • Mar 20, 2020
    • #14

    Work in what sense?

    If you say, on its own, “I have been working here”, it answers a question such as What have you been doing here? or Where have you been working? It does not answer the question “Why is everything in a mess?”. This is all about non-sequiturs.

    S

    stephenlearner

    Senior Member

    Chinese

    • Mar 20, 2020
    • #15

    stephenlearner said:

    I worked in another company a while ago. Later I came to this company. I have been working in this company. It's a very difficult work experience. I decide to quit it and change a company.

    What if I say "I have been working as a salesman in this company"?

    Florentia52

    Modwoman in the attic

    Wisconsin

    English - United States

    • Mar 20, 2020
    • #16

    You're still not coming up with a reason to use the present perfect continuous. "I work as a salesman in this company" is twhat we would normally say.

    The following would work:

    I have been working as a salesman in this company since 2014.
    I have been working as a salesman in this company because I needed a job and they have no other positions available.
    I have been working as a salesman in this company, but I plan to look for a new job soon.

    S

    stephenlearner

    Senior Member

    Chinese

    • Mar 21, 2020
    • #17

    Florentia52 said:

    "I work as a salesman in this company" is what we would normally say.

    To me, "I work as a salesman in this company“ means "Now I work as a salesman in this company", but it does not say what job you used to do. Maybe I used to work as a salesman too, but maybe I used to work as an HR manager.

    S

    stephenlearner

    Senior Member

    Chinese

    • Mar 21, 2020
    • #18

    In the following contexts, is it OK to omit the time reference in the parentheses?
    1. My hands are very dirty. I've been painting the house ( for two hours).
    2. Dad: Where is Peter? I asked him to weed the garden. But there is no progress at all. Mom: He has been playing games on his phone (for two hours).
    3. I have been reading your grammar book (for three days). After I finish it, I'll discuss some problems with you.

    Last edited:

    lingobingo

    Senior Member

    London

    English - England

    • Mar 21, 2020
    • #19

    In all of those examples, what someone has been doing can logically be related to the context you’ve given (there’s an implied conjunction joining the two statements). When it happened is secondary.

    my hands are dirty because
    there’s no progress because
    I’ve been reading the book and [because I’ve found some problems] will discuss it when I’ve finished…

    S

    stephenlearner

    Senior Member

    Chinese

    • Mar 21, 2020
    • #20

    Without the time reference, do the sentences still mean the actions (painting, playing games, and reading) continue up to the present, i.e., the time when the speaker is talking?

    lingobingo

    Senior Member

    London

    English - England

    • Mar 21, 2020
    • #21

    Yes. What it doesn’t do is convey anything about the future, what happens next. Only the context, or some other statement, can do that.

    You must log in or register to reply here.

    I have been working in this company [for three years]. (2025)

    References

    Top Articles
    Latest Posts
    Recommended Articles
    Article information

    Author: Sen. Emmett Berge

    Last Updated:

    Views: 5478

    Rating: 5 / 5 (60 voted)

    Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

    Author information

    Name: Sen. Emmett Berge

    Birthday: 1993-06-17

    Address: 787 Elvis Divide, Port Brice, OH 24507-6802

    Phone: +9779049645255

    Job: Senior Healthcare Specialist

    Hobby: Cycling, Model building, Kitesurfing, Origami, Lapidary, Dance, Basketball

    Introduction: My name is Sen. Emmett Berge, I am a funny, vast, charming, courageous, enthusiastic, jolly, famous person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.